{
  "date": "2026-10-16",
  "import_manifest": "research/imports/kimi-2026-10-15/import-manifest.json",
  "geometry": {
    "native_ship": {
      "date": "2026-10-16",
      "FreeCAD": [
        "1",
        "1",
        "4",
        "20260928 (Git shallow)",
        "Unknown",
        "2026/09/28 13:46:34",
        "(HEAD detached at 4fd3bf320)",
        "4fd3bf320d9566a27e60069fc8387448aaa3a094"
      ],
      "source_sha256": "2017ed784828a44002d722219b461f099f2ce543aaeb2514e268bc50aad25202",
      "records": [
        {
          "name": "PortHull",
          "solids": 1,
          "closed": true,
          "valid": true,
          "volume_mm3": 25216818888.781033,
          "faces": 19140
        },
        {
          "name": "StarboardHull",
          "solids": 1,
          "closed": true,
          "valid": true,
          "volume_mm3": 25216818888.781033,
          "faces": 19140
        }
      ],
      "both_positive_closed_valid_solids": true,
      "draft_m": 0.52,
      "mass_kg": 6944.098766779229,
      "volume_m3": 6.774730504174857,
      "LCB_m": -0.6875874950766595,
      "KB_m": 0.32185073179831486,
      "waterplane_m2": 20.579338337549657,
      "IT_m4": 196.40740795743065,
      "IL_origin_m4": 222.3520396414641,
      "waterplanes": 2,
      "elapsed_seconds": 38.477017402648926,
      "source_unchanged": true,
      "status": "PASS"
    },
    "independent_at_052": {
      "draft_m": 0.52,
      "volume_m3": 6.77473050417466,
      "mass_kg": 6944.098766779027,
      "LCB_m": -0.6875874950766016,
      "KB_m": 0.3218507317983106,
      "wetted_area_m2": 33.944293350794126,
      "integral_x2_m5": 56.22020356271863,
      "integral_y2_m5": 64.57054881963307,
      "Awp_m2": 20.579338314239415,
      "LCF_m": -1.1387411857006664,
      "IT_m4": 196.40740788958055,
      "IL_about_LCF_m4": 222.35203917327112
    },
    "relative_errors": {
      "mass": 2.90878432451791e-14,
      "area": 1.1327012661155322e-09,
      "IT": 3.454558861193391e-10,
      "IL": 2.1056383303630355e-09
    },
    "draft_scenarios": [
      {
        "mass_kg": 6500,
        "upright_salt_draft_m": 0.49878868522844155,
        "excess_above_052_kg": -444.09876677902685
      },
      {
        "mass_kg": 6944.098766779,
        "upright_salt_draft_m": 0.5199999999999995,
        "excess_above_052_kg": -2.7284841053187847e-11
      },
      {
        "mass_kg": 7200,
        "upright_salt_draft_m": 0.53208345068186,
        "excess_above_052_kg": 255.90123322097315
      },
      {
        "mass_kg": 7202,
        "upright_salt_draft_m": 0.5321775222582525,
        "excess_above_052_kg": 257.90123322097315
      },
      {
        "mass_kg": 8600,
        "upright_salt_draft_m": 0.59675824672354,
        "excess_above_052_kg": 1655.9012332209732
      }
    ],
    "curve": [
      {
        "draft_m": 0.4,
        "volume_m3": 4.450308529825456,
        "mass_kg": 4561.566243071093,
        "LCB_m": -0.5260710845353053,
        "KB_m": 0.24897755993871315,
        "wetted_area_m2": 26.362799604757562,
        "integral_x2_m5": 30.19009172301061,
        "integral_y2_m5": 42.39815773143028
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.42000000000000004,
        "volume_m3": 4.815005716781206,
        "mass_kg": 4935.380859700736,
        "LCB_m": -0.550851760362298,
        "KB_m": 0.26117696327607687,
        "wetted_area_m2": 27.609449649302736,
        "integral_x2_m5": 33.91507969928343,
        "integral_y2_m5": 45.87579370135696
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.44,
        "volume_m3": 5.189081755789754,
        "mass_kg": 5318.808799684498,
        "LCB_m": -0.5765906432989018,
        "KB_m": 0.2733502496426887,
        "wetted_area_m2": 28.870859503169868,
        "integral_x2_m5": 37.88494577262114,
        "integral_y2_m5": 49.443102967416365
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.46,
        "volume_m3": 5.572420075430281,
        "mass_kg": 5711.730577316038,
        "LCB_m": -0.6032366695309813,
        "KB_m": 0.28550509670673807,
        "wetted_area_m2": 30.148489390603565,
        "integral_x2_m5": 42.105093882101784,
        "integral_y2_m5": 53.09922168721197
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.48000000000000004,
        "volume_m3": 5.964823328627219,
        "mass_kg": 6113.943911842899,
        "LCB_m": -0.6307568902324385,
        "KB_m": 0.2976448080632364,
        "wetted_area_m2": 31.440089303969735,
        "integral_x2_m5": 46.577288165198325,
        "integral_y2_m5": 56.84244045633926
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.5,
        "volume_m3": 6.366009627207098,
        "mass_kg": 6525.159867887275,
        "LCB_m": -0.6592664610545044,
        "KB_m": 0.30976932771187715,
        "wetted_area_m2": 32.745678474207125,
        "integral_x2_m5": 51.299016399064286,
        "integral_y2_m5": 60.67017519323882
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.52,
        "volume_m3": 6.77473050417466,
        "mass_kg": 6944.098766779027,
        "LCB_m": -0.6875874950766016,
        "KB_m": 0.3218507317983106,
        "wetted_area_m2": 33.944293350794126,
        "integral_x2_m5": 56.22020356271863,
        "integral_y2_m5": 64.57054881963307
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.54,
        "volume_m3": 7.188984640487439,
        "mass_kg": 7368.709256499625,
        "LCB_m": -0.714002383118559,
        "KB_m": 0.3338462216835002,
        "wetted_area_m2": 35.11477387316454,
        "integral_x2_m5": 61.25209950562072,
        "integral_y2_m5": 68.52458873199801
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.56,
        "volume_m3": 7.608133437187827,
        "mass_kg": 7798.336773117522,
        "LCB_m": -0.7382699296451934,
        "KB_m": 0.3457556270782046,
        "wetted_area_m2": 36.268104853542184,
        "integral_x2_m5": 66.36697005537539,
        "integral_y2_m5": 72.52611551448672
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.5800000000000001,
        "volume_m3": 8.031808247513299,
        "mass_kg": 8232.603453701131,
        "LCB_m": -0.7604112534387593,
        "KB_m": 0.35758535891152166,
        "wetted_area_m2": 37.41632755073222,
        "integral_x2_m5": 71.54827282616012,
        "integral_y2_m5": 76.57155608509862
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.6000000000000001,
        "volume_m3": 8.459940987812555,
        "mass_kg": 8671.439512507868,
        "LCB_m": -0.780660912859824,
        "KB_m": 0.36934805721215114,
        "wetted_area_m2": 38.56439457880978,
        "integral_x2_m5": 76.79271427915788,
        "integral_y2_m5": 80.66025298144876
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.62,
        "volume_m3": 8.892519611260287,
        "mass_kg": 9114.832601541793,
        "LCB_m": -0.7992585507971054,
        "KB_m": 0.3810554582191173,
        "wetted_area_m2": 39.71257798521465,
        "integral_x2_m5": 82.09970827667762,
        "integral_y2_m5": 84.79209399844088
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.64,
        "volume_m3": 9.329542693841848,
        "mass_kg": 9562.781261187894,
        "LCB_m": -0.8164126299364317,
        "KB_m": 0.3927175429551799,
        "wetted_area_m2": 40.86097469749258,
        "integral_x2_m5": 87.46901457713076,
        "integral_y2_m5": 88.96704795472212
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.66,
        "volume_m3": 9.771006363895607,
        "mass_kg": 10015.281522992997,
        "LCB_m": -0.8323004549088223,
        "KB_m": 0.40434257406390783,
        "wetted_area_m2": 42.00948115231798,
        "integral_x2_m5": 92.900400677144,
        "integral_y2_m5": 93.18506406778664
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.68,
        "volume_m3": 10.216901691856156,
        "mass_kg": 10472.32423415256,
        "LCB_m": -0.8470685216119921,
        "KB_m": 0.4159373594587751,
        "wetted_area_m2": 43.158060563539195,
        "integral_x2_m5": 98.39348822779574,
        "integral_y2_m5": 97.4460320190948
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.7,
        "volume_m3": 10.667219878395702,
        "mass_kg": 10933.900375355595,
        "LCB_m": -0.8608414884958543,
        "KB_m": 0.42750764287202664,
        "wetted_area_m2": 44.30680693886511,
        "integral_x2_m5": 103.9478668895188,
        "integral_y2_m5": 101.74985906465727
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.72,
        "volume_m3": 11.12195511343159,
        "mass_kg": 11400.003991267378,
        "LCB_m": -0.8737274661249382,
        "KB_m": 0.4390583625374618,
        "wetted_area_m2": 45.45584146765084,
        "integral_x2_m5": 109.56316612110797,
        "integral_y2_m5": 106.09647102937538
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.74,
        "volume_m3": 11.581104094409651,
        "mass_kg": 11870.631696769893,
        "LCB_m": -0.8858216043978747,
        "KB_m": 0.4505937834982959,
        "wetted_area_m2": 46.605217933931996,
        "integral_x2_m5": 115.23906746761348,
        "integral_y2_m5": 110.48581194725837
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.76,
        "volume_m3": 12.044660535942157,
        "mass_kg": 12345.777049340712,
        "LCB_m": -0.8972041807252662,
        "KB_m": 0.4621174806861148,
        "wetted_area_m2": 47.75479987012791,
        "integral_x2_m5": 120.97522472305454,
        "integral_y2_m5": 114.91779589327764
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.78,
        "volume_m3": 12.512619022730071,
        "mass_kg": 12825.434498298322,
        "LCB_m": -0.9079419399344094,
        "KB_m": 0.4736325414583274,
        "wetted_area_m2": 48.90463363942892,
        "integral_x2_m5": 126.7712646938433,
        "integral_y2_m5": 119.39234258055487
      },
      {
        "draft_m": 0.8,
        "volume_m3": 12.98497511665846,
        "mass_kg": 13309.59949457492,
        "LCB_m": -0.9180944373966369,
        "KB_m": 0.48514164572043117,
        "wetted_area_m2": 50.05489283273343,
        "integral_x2_m5": 132.62686635750475,
        "integral_y2_m5": 123.90936247336457
      }
    ],
    "imported_curve": [
      {
        "T": 0.4,
        "Ywl": -0.09,
        "V_m3": 4.397,
        "D_salt_t": 4.51,
        "D_fresh_t": 4.4,
        "A_wl": 17.91,
        "S_wet": 30.31,
        "L_wl": 12.34,
        "KB": 0.25,
        "LCB_from_stern": 7.651,
        "BM_trans": 38.858,
        "B_wl_hull": 0.92,
        "s_CB": 6.159
      },
      {
        "T": 0.45,
        "Ywl": -0.04,
        "V_m3": 5.328,
        "D_salt_t": 5.46,
        "D_fresh_t": 5.33,
        "A_wl": 19.16,
        "S_wet": 44.62,
        "L_wl": 12.96,
        "KB": 0.281,
        "LCB_from_stern": 7.711,
        "BM_trans": 34.3,
        "B_wl_hull": 0.96,
        "s_CB": 6.159
      },
      {
        "T": 0.5,
        "Ywl": 0.01,
        "V_m3": 6.312,
        "D_salt_t": 6.47,
        "D_fresh_t": 6.31,
        "A_wl": 20.14,
        "S_wet": 49.07,
        "L_wl": 13.5,
        "KB": 0.311,
        "LCB_from_stern": 7.778,
        "BM_trans": 30.453,
        "B_wl_hull": 0.96,
        "s_CB": 6.159
      },
      {
        "T": 0.6,
        "Ywl": 0.11,
        "V_m3": 8.4,
        "D_salt_t": 8.61,
        "D_fresh_t": 8.4,
        "A_wl": 21.43,
        "S_wet": 57.58,
        "L_wl": 13.56,
        "KB": 0.371,
        "LCB_from_stern": 7.9,
        "BM_trans": 24.35,
        "B_wl_hull": 1.0,
        "s_CB": 6.158
      },
      {
        "T": 0.7,
        "Ywl": 0.21,
        "V_m3": 10.604,
        "D_salt_t": 10.87,
        "D_fresh_t": 10.6,
        "A_wl": 22.63,
        "S_wet": 66.81,
        "L_wl": 13.56,
        "KB": 0.429,
        "LCB_from_stern": 7.98,
        "BM_trans": 20.385,
        "B_wl_hull": 1.08,
        "s_CB": 6.158
      },
      {
        "T": 0.8,
        "Ywl": 0.31,
        "V_m3": 12.919,
        "D_salt_t": 13.24,
        "D_fresh_t": 12.92,
        "A_wl": 23.76,
        "S_wet": 75.75,
        "L_wl": 13.56,
        "KB": 0.486,
        "LCB_from_stern": 8.037,
        "BM_trans": 17.592,
        "B_wl_hull": 1.12,
        "s_CB": 6.158
      },
      {
        "T": 0.9,
        "Ywl": 0.41,
        "V_m3": 15.362,
        "D_salt_t": 15.75,
        "D_fresh_t": 15.36,
        "A_wl": 25.53,
        "S_wet": 85.91,
        "L_wl": 13.56,
        "KB": 0.544,
        "LCB_from_stern": 8.081,
        "BM_trans": 15.651,
        "B_wl_hull": 1.2,
        "s_CB": 6.156
      },
      {
        "T": 1.0,
        "Ywl": 0.51,
        "V_m3": 18.065,
        "D_salt_t": 18.52,
        "D_fresh_t": 18.06,
        "A_wl": 28.56,
        "S_wet": 98.84,
        "L_wl": 13.56,
        "KB": 0.605,
        "LCB_from_stern": 8.127,
        "BM_trans": 14.364,
        "B_wl_hull": 1.38,
        "s_CB": 6.139
      }
    ],
    "upper_lid_z_m": 0.926000425,
    "coordinate_example": {
      "kimi_LCB_from_labelled_stern_m": 7.82,
      "obj_x_min_m": -6.51206,
      "source_raw_x_m": 1.3079400000000003,
      "canonical_x_m": 6.096760195312499,
      "calculation_x_m": -0.7032398046875006
    },
    "coordinate_transform_candidate": "For OBJ Y-up: Xcanon=7404.700195-Xobj; Ycanon=Zobj; Zcanon=Yobj (mm). Xcalc=Xcanon-6800, Zcalc=Zcanon+486.100006. Verify anchors before importing any loads/CG.",
    "baseline_vertical_offset_m": 0.0038999940000000177
  },
  "trim": {
    "lever_m": -0.219,
    "assumed_GM_L_m": 39.0,
    "length_m": 13.5,
    "import_formula_deg": -0.9293833477167892,
    "linear_equilibrium_deg": -0.3217344571306508,
    "linear_draft_difference_m": -0.07580769230769231,
    "MCTC_kNm_cm": 2.04048,
    "scope": "same hypothetical inputs, not actual vessel equilibrium; real CG and frame mapping not known"
  },
  "controller": {
    "dt_s": 0.05,
    "first_entry_5pct_s": 0.5999999999999881,
    "last_exit_then_in_band_to_20s_s": 3.1999999999999815,
    "gust_peak_kN": 7.056000000000001,
    "log": [
      [
        0.0,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.05,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.1,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.15000000000000002,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.2,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.25,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.3,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.35,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.39999999999999997,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.44999999999999996,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.49999999999999994,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.5499999999999999,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.6,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.65,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.7000000000000001,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.7500000000000001,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.8000000000000002,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.8500000000000002,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.9000000000000002,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        0.9500000000000003,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.0000000000000002,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.0500000000000003,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.1000000000000003,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.1500000000000004,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.2000000000000004,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.2500000000000004,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.3000000000000005,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.3500000000000005,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.4000000000000006,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.4500000000000006,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.5000000000000007,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.5500000000000007,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.6000000000000008,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.6500000000000008,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.7000000000000008,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.7500000000000009,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.800000000000001,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.850000000000001,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.900000000000001,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        1.950000000000001,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.000000000000001,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.0500000000000007,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.1000000000000005,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.1500000000000004,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.2,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.25,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.3,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.3499999999999996,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.3999999999999995,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.4499999999999993,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.499999999999999,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.549999999999999,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.5999999999999988,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.6499999999999986,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.6999999999999984,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.7499999999999982,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.799999999999998,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.849999999999998,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.8999999999999977,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.9499999999999975,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        2.9999999999999973,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.049999999999997,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.099999999999997,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.149999999999997,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.1999999999999966,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.2499999999999964,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.2999999999999963,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.349999999999996,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.399999999999996,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.4499999999999957,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.4999999999999956,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.5499999999999954,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.599999999999995,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.649999999999995,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.699999999999995,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.7499999999999947,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.7999999999999945,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.8499999999999943,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.899999999999994,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.949999999999994,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        3.999999999999994,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.049999999999994,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.099999999999993,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.149999999999993,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.199999999999993,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.249999999999993,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.299999999999993,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.3499999999999925,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.399999999999992,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.449999999999992,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.499999999999992,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.549999999999992,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.599999999999992,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.6499999999999915,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.699999999999991,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.749999999999991,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.799999999999991,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.849999999999991,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.899999999999991,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.94999999999999,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        4.99999999999999,
        3.136,
        1.0,
        8.0
      ],
      [
        5.04999999999999,
        7.056000000000001,
        0.957668,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.09999999999999,
        6.757305408000001,
        0.911065745232,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.14999999999999,
        6.428479898356993,
        0.8613097295632344,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.1999999999999895,
        6.077401451798183,
        0.809468041209908,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.249999999999989,
        5.711606498777112,
        0.7565476751470964,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.299999999999989,
        5.338200395837913,
        0.7034839344803896,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.349999999999989,
        4.96378264169363,
        0.6511319047966756,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.399999999999989,
        4.5943867202453434,
        0.6002599540105132,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.449999999999989,
        4.235434235498182,
        0.5515451822538193,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.4999999999999885,
        3.8917028059829497,
        0.5055707220526043,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.549999999999988,
        3.5673070148031765,
        0.46282476845782927,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.599999999999988,
        3.2656915662384436,
        0.4237012019460769,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.649999999999988,
        2.989635680931519,
        0.38850165371856515,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.699999999999988,
        2.741267668638196,
        0.35743885339028403,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.749999999999988,
        2.5220885495218446,
        0.35,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.799999999999987,
        2.4696000000000002,
        0.35,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.849999999999987,
        2.4696000000000002,
        0.35,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.899999999999987,
        2.4696000000000002,
        0.35,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.949999999999987,
        2.4696000000000002,
        0.35,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        5.999999999999987,
        2.4696000000000002,
        0.35,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.0499999999999865,
        2.4696000000000002,
        0.35,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.099999999999986,
        2.4696000000000002,
        0.35,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.149999999999986,
        2.4696000000000002,
        0.35,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.199999999999986,
        2.4696000000000002,
        0.35,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.249999999999986,
        2.4696000000000002,
        0.35,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.299999999999986,
        2.4696000000000002,
        0.35,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.349999999999985,
        2.4696000000000002,
        0.35,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.399999999999985,
        2.4696000000000002,
        0.35,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.449999999999985,
        2.4696000000000002,
        0.35,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.499999999999985,
        2.4696000000000002,
        0.35,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.549999999999985,
        2.4696000000000002,
        0.3501527462932721,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.5999999999999845,
        2.4706777778453284,
        0.3519329953633257,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.649999999999984,
        2.4832392152836262,
        0.35516893823101237,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.699999999999984,
        2.5060720281580235,
        0.3596808088744135,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.749999999999984,
        2.537907787417862,
        0.36528444000537647,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.799999999999984,
        2.577447008677937,
        0.3717945751010632,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.849999999999984,
        2.623382521913102,
        0.3790279056070059,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.8999999999999835,
        2.674420901963034,
        0.3868058093329076,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.949999999999983,
        2.7293017906529964,
        0.3949567729212155,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        6.999999999999983,
        2.786814989732097,
        0.4033184877941374,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.049999999999983,
        2.845815249875434,
        0.4117396151030479,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.099999999999983,
        2.9052347241671064,
        0.4200812208539365,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.149999999999983,
        2.9640930943453765,
        0.42821788751531964,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.199999999999982,
        3.0215054143080957,
        0.4360385129949756,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.249999999999982,
        3.076687747692548,
        0.4434468118750176,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.299999999999982,
        3.1289607045901247,
        0.4503615372085122,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.349999999999982,
        3.1777510065432626,
        0.4567164440028702,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.399999999999982,
        3.2225912288842524,
        0.46246001775297624,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.4499999999999815,
        3.2631178852650007,
        0.4675549930564767,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.499999999999981,
        3.2990680310065,
        0.4719776884684438,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.549999999999981,
        3.33027456983334,
        0.47571718436295035,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.599999999999981,
        3.356660452864978,
        0.47877437070061524,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.649999999999981,
        3.3782319596635415,
        0.4811608912940551,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.699999999999981,
        3.395071248970853,
        0.4828980104609692,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.7499999999999805,
        3.407328361812599,
        0.4840154269032831,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.79999999999998,
        3.415212852229566,
        0.48455005829786835,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.84999999999998,
        3.4189852113497596,
        0.48454481847791425,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.89999999999998,
        3.4189482391801636,
        0.4840474072719247,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.94999999999998,
        3.4154385057107013,
        0.48310913109645437,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        7.99999999999998,
        3.4088180290165826,
        0.48178377031437325,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.04999999999998,
        3.399466283338218,
        0.48012650721576067,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.09999999999998,
        3.3877726349144077,
        0.4781929262938883,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.14999999999998,
        3.3741292879296765,
        0.4760380963114833,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.199999999999982,
        3.3589248075738265,
        0.4737157415164853,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.249999999999982,
        3.3425382721403207,
        0.47127750730209045,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.299999999999983,
        3.3253340915235508,
        0.4687723236394772,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.349999999999984,
        3.3076575156001513,
        0.46624586776580607,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.399999999999984,
        3.289830842955528,
        0.4637401259035428,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.449999999999985,
        3.2721503283753983,
        0.46129305223468653,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.499999999999986,
        3.2548837765679486,
        0.4589383219661455,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.549999999999986,
        3.238268799793123,
        0.45670517410775524,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.599999999999987,
        3.2225117085043213,
        0.4546183385463403,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.649999999999988,
        3.2077869967829775,
        0.45269804113868045,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.699999999999989,
        3.1942373782745297,
        0.4509600798612585,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.74999999999999,
        3.1819743235010405,
        0.4494159645406279,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.79999999999999,
        3.171079045798671,
        0.44807311233822983,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.84999999999999,
        3.16160388065855,
        0.44693509096860157,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.899999999999991,
        3.153574001874453,
        0.446001901579557,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.949999999999992,
        3.1469894175453548,
        0.4452702933051491,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        8.999999999999993,
        3.1418271895611327,
        0.44473410170403144,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.049999999999994,
        3.138043821623646,
        0.44438460360347914,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.099999999999994,
        3.1355777630261494,
        0.4442108812685867,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.149999999999995,
        3.134351978231148,
        0.44420018929261174,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.199999999999996,
        3.134276535648669,
        0.4443383181437083,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.249999999999996,
        3.135251172822006,
        0.4446099488912886,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.299999999999997,
        3.1371677993769325,
        0.44499899425833417,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.349999999999998,
        3.1399129034868065,
        0.44548892179116106,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.399999999999999,
        3.1433698321584327,
        0.44606305559323617,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.45,
        3.147420920265875,
        0.44670485372337,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.5,
        3.151949447872099,
        0.4473981590007138,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.55,
        3.156841409909037,
        0.4481274215803005,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.600000000000001,
        3.161987086670601,
        0.44887789225535885,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.650000000000002,
        3.1672824077538126,
        0.44963578599943094,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.700000000000003,
        3.1726301060119853,
        0.45038841577674893,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.750000000000004,
        3.177940661720741,
        0.45112429711883584,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.800000000000004,
        3.1831330404705063,
        0.451833224385492,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.850000000000005,
        3.188135231264032,
        0.452506319996885,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.900000000000006,
        3.1928845938980213,
        0.4531360582390826,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        9.950000000000006,
        3.1973280269349673,
        0.4537162655077147,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.000000000000007,
        3.2014219694224355,
        0.45424209906405294,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.050000000000008,
        3.205132250995958,
        0.4547100065359813,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.100000000000009,
        3.2084338061178848,
        0.4551176685051203,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.15000000000001,
        3.211310268972129,
        0.45546392658339396,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.20000000000001,
        3.2137534659724283,
        0.45574869940072593,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.25000000000001,
        3.2157628229715227,
        0.45597288890388327,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.300000000000011,
        3.217344704105801,
        0.4561382793086241,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.350000000000012,
        3.218511698801652,
        0.4562474309573631,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.400000000000013,
        3.2192818728351544,
        0.4563035712168042,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.450000000000014,
        3.219677998505771,
        0.4563104844087246,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.500000000000014,
        3.2197267779879613,
        0.45627240260664476,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.550000000000015,
        3.2194580727924857,
        0.45619389895572526,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.600000000000016,
        3.218904151031598,
        0.45607978498699575,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.650000000000016,
        3.2180989628682424,
        0.45593501320385466,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.700000000000017,
        3.217077453166399,
        0.45576458602236214,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.750000000000018,
        3.2158749189737876,
        0.4555734719505863,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.800000000000018,
        3.214526418083337,
        0.45536652969925356,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.85000000000002,
        3.2130662335579334,
        0.45514844072898303,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.90000000000002,
        3.211527397783705,
        0.454923650560877,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        10.95000000000002,
        3.2099412783575487,
        0.45469631900929347,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.000000000000021,
        3.2083372269295753,
        0.45447027933996803,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.050000000000022,
        3.206742291022815,
        0.45424900621467573,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.100000000000023,
        3.2051809878507522,
        0.45403559215637007,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.150000000000023,
        3.2036751382553477,
        0.45383273215693243,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.200000000000024,
        3.2022437580993155,
        0.45364271595372174,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.250000000000025,
        3.200903003769461,
        0.4534674274211529,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.300000000000026,
        3.1996661678836555,
        0.4533083504594185,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.350000000000026,
        3.1985437208416574,
        0.45316658071381527,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.400000000000027,
        3.197543393516681,
        0.45304284242436177,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.450000000000028,
        3.196670296146297,
        0.4529375096857089,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.500000000000028,
        3.195927068342362,
        0.45285063139083487,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.55000000000003,
        3.195314055093731,
        0.4527819591376078,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.60000000000003,
        3.194829503674961,
        0.4527309773938467,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.65000000000003,
        3.194469776490983,
        0.45269693524278065,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.700000000000031,
        3.1942295750730607,
        0.45267887906552423,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.750000000000032,
        3.1941021706863393,
        0.4526756855590576,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.800000000000033,
        3.1940796373047107,
        0.4526860945359257,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.850000000000033,
        3.194153083045492,
        0.4527087410041817,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.900000000000034,
        3.1943128765255064,
        0.4527421860817551,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        11.950000000000035,
        3.194548864992864,
        0.4527849463572526,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.000000000000036,
        3.1948505814967745,
        0.4528355213680834,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.050000000000036,
        3.195207438773197,
        0.4528924189257193,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.100000000000037,
        3.1956089079398757,
        0.452954178075907,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.150000000000038,
        3.1960446805036002,
        0.45301938953791504,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.200000000000038,
        3.196504812579529,
        0.45308671352067,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.250000000000039,
        3.196979850601848,
        0.45315489486429184,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.30000000000004,
        3.1974609381624437,
        0.4532227755025407,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.35000000000004,
        3.1979399039459278,
        0.45328930428461767,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.400000000000041,
        3.1984093310322628,
        0.45335354423329294,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.450000000000042,
        3.1988626081101152,
        0.45341467735024726,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.500000000000043,
        3.199293963383345,
        0.4534720071086737,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.550000000000043,
        3.199698482158802,
        0.45352495879754956,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.600000000000044,
        3.20007210927551,
        0.4535730779015967,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.650000000000045,
        3.2004116376736667,
        0.4536160267159011,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.700000000000045,
        3.200714684507399,
        0.4536535794046423,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.750000000000046,
        3.2009796562791566,
        0.45368561571960836,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.800000000000047,
        3.201205704517557,
        0.45371211359642993,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.850000000000048,
        3.20139267353641,
        0.4537331408450589,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.900000000000048,
        3.201541041802736,
        0.4537488461463026,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        12.950000000000049,
        3.2016518584083116,
        0.45375944955855796,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.00000000000005,
        3.2017266760851855,
        0.4537652327286607,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.05000000000005,
        3.2017674821334303,
        0.4537665289883602,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.100000000000051,
        3.20177662854187,
        0.45376371350373496,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.150000000000052,
        3.201756762482354,
        0.4537571936292684,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.200000000000053,
        3.2017107582481183,
        0.45374739960167154,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.250000000000053,
        3.201641651589395,
        0.45373477569123255,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.300000000000054,
        3.2015525772773374,
        0.45371977191082025,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.350000000000055,
        3.201446710602748,
        0.45370283636498415,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.400000000000055,
        3.2013272133913286,
        0.45368440830416035,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.450000000000056,
        3.2011971849941556,
        0.4536649119320643,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.500000000000057,
        3.2010596185926463,
        0.4536447509981537,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.550000000000058,
        3.200917363042973,
        0.4536243041917673,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.600000000000058,
        3.2007730903771106,
        0.4536039213403557,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.650000000000059,
        3.20062926897755,
        0.45358392040123907,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.70000000000006,
        3.2004881423511433,
        0.4535645852246625,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.75000000000006,
        3.200351713345219,
        0.45354616405563325,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.800000000000061,
        3.200221733576549,
        0.4535288687331651,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.850000000000062,
        3.2000996977812135,
        0.45351287453813094,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.900000000000063,
        3.1999868427410525,
        0.45349832063493145,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        13.950000000000063,
        3.199884150400077,
        0.45348531104759393,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.000000000000064,
        3.199792354751823,
        0.453473916107668,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.050000000000065,
        3.199711952055706,
        0.4534641743093182,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.100000000000065,
        3.1996432139265494,
        0.4534560945062481,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.150000000000066,
        3.1995862028360866,
        0.45344965838542756,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.200000000000067,
        3.1995407895675774,
        0.45344482315393636,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.250000000000068,
        3.1995066721741754,
        0.4534415243774708,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.300000000000068,
        3.1994833960074347,
        0.4534396789120728,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.350000000000069,
        3.199470374403586,
        0.45343918787431486,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.40000000000007,
        3.199466909641166,
        0.45343993959939455,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.45000000000007,
        3.1994722138133285,
        0.45344181254124216,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.500000000000071,
        3.199485429291005,
        0.4534446780737141,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.550000000000072,
        3.199505648488127,
        0.4534484031571237,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.600000000000072,
        3.199531932676665,
        0.4534528528396541,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.650000000000073,
        3.1995633296365997,
        0.45345789256850294,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.700000000000074,
        3.199598889963357,
        0.4534633902908498,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.750000000000075,
        3.1996376818922365,
        0.45346921832982817,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.800000000000075,
        3.199678804535268,
        0.45347525502556424,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.850000000000076,
        3.1997213994603815,
        0.45348138613595057,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.900000000000077,
        3.199764660575268,
        0.45348750599610643,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        14.950000000000077,
        3.199807842308527,
        0.4534935184394024,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.000000000000078,
        3.199850266108424,
        0.45349933748645566,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.050000000000079,
        3.1998913253044314,
        0.45350488781162385,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.10000000000008,
        3.1999304883988184,
        0.4535101049992149,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.15000000000008,
        3.199967300874461,
        0.4535149356038929,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.200000000000081,
        3.2000013856210687,
        0.45351933703159086,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.250000000000082,
        3.2000324420949053,
        0.4535232772586523,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.300000000000082,
        3.200060244337051,
        0.45352673440792857,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.350000000000083,
        3.200084637982344,
        0.45352969620117844,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.400000000000084,
        3.2001055363955153,
        0.45353215930737373,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.450000000000085,
        3.2001229160728295,
        0.4535341286064387,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.500000000000085,
        3.200136811447032,
        0.45353561638757034,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.550000000000086,
        3.200147309230697,
        0.4535366415006371,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.600000000000087,
        3.200154542428496,
        0.4535372284782673,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.650000000000087,
        3.200158684142654,
        0.4535374066451495,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.700000000000088,
        3.2001599412881756,
        0.45353720922981433,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.750000000000089,
        3.2001585483255703,
        0.4535366724927792,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.80000000000009,
        3.2001547611090504,
        0.45353583488345517,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.85000000000009,
        3.20014885093766,
        0.4535347362366638,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.900000000000091,
        3.2001410988859003,
        0.45353341701802613,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        15.950000000000092,
        3.2001317904791926,
        0.4535319176258941,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.000000000000092,
        3.2001212107683092,
        0.4535302777559195,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.050000000000093,
        3.2001096398457682,
        0.45352853583282365,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.100000000000094,
        3.200097348836404,
        0.4535267285124629,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.150000000000095,
        3.2000845963839386,
        0.45352489025589415,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.200000000000095,
        3.2000716256455894,
        0.4535230529758522,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.250000000000096,
        3.2000586617976134,
        0.4535212457548653,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.300000000000097,
        3.20004591004633,
        0.4535194946331652,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.350000000000097,
        3.2000335541316143,
        0.4535178224636029,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.400000000000098,
        3.2000217553031822,
        0.45351624882996383,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.4500000000001,
        3.200010651744225,
        0.45351479002438727,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.5000000000001,
        3.200000358412077,
        0.45351345907903534,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.5500000000001,
        3.199990967261674,
        0.4535122658467247,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.6000000000001,
        3.19998254781449,
        0.45351121712492126,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.6500000000001,
        3.199975148033445,
        0.45351031681730564,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.700000000000102,
        3.199968795462909,
        0.4535095661270302,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.750000000000103,
        3.1999634985923255,
        0.4535089637758043,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.800000000000104,
        3.1999592484020756,
        0.45350850624305183,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.850000000000104,
        3.199956020050974,
        0.45350818801957343,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.900000000000105,
        3.1999537746661106,
        0.4535080018704071,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        16.950000000000106,
        3.1999524611975927,
        0.4535079391019026,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.000000000000107,
        3.1999520183030254,
        0.45350798982839846,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.050000000000107,
        3.19995237622918,
        0.4535081432343017,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.100000000000108,
        3.1999534586612333,
        0.4535083878278165,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.15000000000011,
        3.199955184513074,
        0.45350871168302886,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.20000000000011,
        3.1999574696354522,
        0.45350910266753175,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.25000000000011,
        3.1999602284221043,
        0.45350954865325177,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.30000000000011,
        3.199963375297345,
        0.45351003770861226,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.35000000000011,
        3.1999668260719685,
        0.453510558270628,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.400000000000112,
        3.1999704991575513,
        0.45351109929596944,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.450000000000113,
        3.199974316632361,
        0.45351165039045294,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.500000000000114,
        3.1999782051550363,
        0.4535122019168042,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.550000000000114,
        3.1999820967249706,
        0.4535127450809001,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.600000000000115,
        3.1999859292908317,
        0.45351327199701835,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.650000000000116,
        3.199989647210962,
        0.45351377573291035,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.700000000000117,
        3.1999932015714156,
        0.453514250335761,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.750000000000117,
        3.19999655036913,
        0.45351469084030965,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.800000000000118,
        3.1999996585692254,
        0.4535150932605763,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.85000000000012,
        3.200002498046627,
        0.45351545456677056,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.90000000000012,
        3.2000050474231334,
        0.45351577264905646,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        17.95000000000012,
        3.2000072918117426,
        0.4535160462699083,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.00000000000012,
        3.2000092224804737,
        0.45351627500682,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.05000000000012,
        3.2000108364481226,
        0.4535164591871278,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.100000000000122,
        3.200012136024374,
        0.4535165998166776,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.150000000000123,
        3.200013128306477,
        0.4535166985040115,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.200000000000124,
        3.2000138246443055,
        0.45351675738167285,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.250000000000124,
        3.200014240085084,
        0.4535167790261331,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.300000000000125,
        3.2000143928083955,
        0.453516766377733,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.350000000000126,
        3.2000143035612845,
        0.45351672266190896,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.400000000000126,
        3.20001399510243,
        0.45351665131284014,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.450000000000127,
        3.2000134916634004,
        0.4535165559005165,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.500000000000128,
        3.2000128184340446,
        0.4535164400620832,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.55000000000013,
        3.2000120010780595,
        0.45351630743817406,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.60000000000013,
        3.2000110652837566,
        0.4535161616148053,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.65000000000013,
        3.2000100363540667,
        0.45351600607126097,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.70000000000013,
        3.2000089388388178,
        0.45351584413426993,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.75000000000013,
        3.200007796211409,
        0.4535156789386458,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.800000000000132,
        3.2000066305910853,
        0.4535155133944458,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.850000000000133,
        3.2000054625112098,
        0.453515350160594,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.900000000000134,
        3.200004310733152,
        0.45351519162481835,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        18.950000000000134,
        3.2000031921047185,
        0.4535150398896625,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.000000000000135,
        3.200002121461459,
        0.45351489676425916,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.050000000000136,
        3.200001111568613,
        0.45351476376148697,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.100000000000136,
        3.2000001731010523,
        0.4535146421000819,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.150000000000137,
        3.199999314658178,
        0.45351453271123193,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.200000000000138,
        3.199998542810453,
        0.45351443624915494,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.25000000000014,
        3.1999978621740377,
        0.45351435310514154,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.30000000000014,
        3.199997275509879,
        0.453514283424533,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.35000000000014,
        3.1999967838435053,
        0.4535142271261062,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.40000000000014,
        3.1999963866018057,
        0.4535141839233465,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.45000000000014,
        3.1999960817631337,
        0.45351415334710327,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.500000000000142,
        3.199995866017161,
        0.45351413476914604,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.550000000000143,
        3.199995734931095,
        0.4535141274261697,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.600000000000144,
        3.1999956831190537,
        0.45351413044382594,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.650000000000144,
        3.199995704411636,
        0.45351414286039876,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.700000000000145,
        3.1999957920229742,
        0.45351416364977815,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.750000000000146,
        3.199995938712835,
        0.4535141917434304,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.800000000000146,
        3.199996136941645,
        0.4535142260511038,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.850000000000147,
        3.199996379016589,
        0.4535142654800531,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.900000000000148,
        3.199996657227255,
        0.45351430895260775,
        12.0
      ],
      [
        19.95000000000015,
        3.1999969639696006,
        0.4535143554219515,
        12.0
      ]
    ],
    "model": "instant algebraic force; no actuator, line dynamics, moving base, transport delay or sensor noise",
    "controller": "u[k+1]=clip(u[k]+Kp*e*dt+Ki*integral(e)*dt); not the standard positional PI"
  },
  "propulsion": [
    {
      "speed_kn": 3.0,
      "import_pair_DC_kW": 0.7723486042207082,
      "pair_propeller_absorption_kW": 0.7105607158830516,
      "DC_with_gear_kW": 0.7962356744543384,
      "DC_with_gear_and_shaft_kW": 0.8124853820962636,
      "gear_eta": 0.97,
      "shaft_eta_scenario": 0.98,
      "motor_controller_eta_scenario": 0.92,
      "scope": "same imported resistance and propeller results; no physical validation"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 4.0,
      "import_pair_DC_kW": 1.7264395960958503,
      "pair_propeller_absorption_kW": 1.5883244284081823,
      "DC_with_gear_kW": 1.7798346351503613,
      "DC_with_gear_and_shaft_kW": 1.8161577909697564,
      "gear_eta": 0.97,
      "shaft_eta_scenario": 0.98,
      "motor_controller_eta_scenario": 0.92,
      "scope": "same imported resistance and propeller results; no physical validation"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 5.0,
      "import_pair_DC_kW": 3.262267475494166,
      "pair_propeller_absorption_kW": 3.001286077454633,
      "DC_with_gear_kW": 3.3631623458702746,
      "DC_with_gear_and_shaft_kW": 3.431798312112525,
      "gear_eta": 0.97,
      "shaft_eta_scenario": 0.98,
      "motor_controller_eta_scenario": 0.92,
      "scope": "same imported resistance and propeller results; no physical validation"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 6.0,
      "import_pair_DC_kW": 5.564611485285997,
      "pair_propeller_absorption_kW": 5.119442566463118,
      "DC_with_gear_kW": 5.736712871428863,
      "DC_with_gear_and_shaft_kW": 5.853788644315166,
      "gear_eta": 0.97,
      "shaft_eta_scenario": 0.98,
      "motor_controller_eta_scenario": 0.92,
      "scope": "same imported resistance and propeller results; no physical validation"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 7.0,
      "import_pair_DC_kW": 8.888310345658168,
      "pair_propeller_absorption_kW": 8.177245518005515,
      "DC_with_gear_kW": 9.163206541915638,
      "DC_with_gear_and_shaft_kW": 9.350210757056773,
      "gear_eta": 0.97,
      "shaft_eta_scenario": 0.98,
      "motor_controller_eta_scenario": 0.92,
      "scope": "same imported resistance and propeller results; no physical validation"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 8.0,
      "import_pair_DC_kW": 13.829356419484816,
      "pair_propeller_absorption_kW": 12.72300790592603,
      "DC_with_gear_kW": 14.257068473695686,
      "DC_with_gear_and_shaft_kW": 14.548029054791517,
      "gear_eta": 0.97,
      "shaft_eta_scenario": 0.98,
      "motor_controller_eta_scenario": 0.92,
      "scope": "same imported resistance and propeller results; no physical validation"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 9.0,
      "import_pair_DC_kW": 20.614864340930392,
      "pair_propeller_absorption_kW": 18.96567519365596,
      "DC_with_gear_kW": 21.252437464876696,
      "DC_with_gear_and_shaft_kW": 21.686160678445606,
      "gear_eta": 0.97,
      "shaft_eta_scenario": 0.98,
      "motor_controller_eta_scenario": 0.92,
      "scope": "same imported resistance and propeller results; no physical validation"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 10.0,
      "import_pair_DC_kW": 32.41936505404976,
      "pair_propeller_absorption_kW": 29.825815849725785,
      "DC_with_gear_kW": 33.422025828917285,
      "DC_with_gear_and_shaft_kW": 34.104107988691105,
      "gear_eta": 0.97,
      "shaft_eta_scenario": 0.98,
      "motor_controller_eta_scenario": 0.92,
      "scope": "same imported resistance and propeller results; no physical validation"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 10.1,
      "import_pair_DC_kW": 33.273383904833516,
      "pair_propeller_absorption_kW": 30.611513192446836,
      "DC_with_gear_kW": 34.30245763384899,
      "DC_with_gear_and_shaft_kW": 35.002507789641825,
      "gear_eta": 0.97,
      "shaft_eta_scenario": 0.98,
      "motor_controller_eta_scenario": 0.92,
      "scope": "same imported resistance and propeller results; no physical validation"
    }
  ],
  "range_common_basis": [
    {
      "speed_kn": 4.0,
      "nominal_kWh": 30.0,
      "usable_for_propulsion_bus_kWh": 15.04,
      "total_DC_kW": 2.0481577909697566,
      "hours": 7.343184234296176,
      "range_nm": 29.372736937184705,
      "assumptions": "SOC90-10, discharge .96, reserve8kWh, hotel232W, no solar/kite; same KIMI resistance"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 4.0,
      "nominal_kWh": 40.0,
      "usable_for_propulsion_bus_kWh": 22.72,
      "total_DC_kW": 2.0481577909697566,
      "hours": 11.09289533266018,
      "range_nm": 44.37158133064072,
      "assumptions": "SOC90-10, discharge .96, reserve8kWh, hotel232W, no solar/kite; same KIMI resistance"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 4.0,
      "nominal_kWh": 48.2304,
      "usable_for_propulsion_bus_kWh": 29.040947200000005,
      "total_DC_kW": 2.0481577909697566,
      "hours": 14.179057555057694,
      "range_nm": 56.71623022023078,
      "assumptions": "SOC90-10, discharge .96, reserve8kWh, hotel232W, no solar/kite; same KIMI resistance"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 6.0,
      "nominal_kWh": 30.0,
      "usable_for_propulsion_bus_kWh": 15.04,
      "total_DC_kW": 6.0857886443151665,
      "hours": 2.4713313062636684,
      "range_nm": 14.827987837582011,
      "assumptions": "SOC90-10, discharge .96, reserve8kWh, hotel232W, no solar/kite; same KIMI resistance"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 6.0,
      "nominal_kWh": 40.0,
      "usable_for_propulsion_bus_kWh": 22.72,
      "total_DC_kW": 6.0857886443151665,
      "hours": 3.7332877179727753,
      "range_nm": 22.39972630783665,
      "assumptions": "SOC90-10, discharge .96, reserve8kWh, hotel232W, no solar/kite; same KIMI resistance"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 6.0,
      "nominal_kWh": 48.2304,
      "usable_for_propulsion_bus_kWh": 29.040947200000005,
      "total_DC_kW": 6.0857886443151665,
      "hours": 4.77192832306584,
      "range_nm": 28.63156993839504,
      "assumptions": "SOC90-10, discharge .96, reserve8kWh, hotel232W, no solar/kite; same KIMI resistance"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 7.0,
      "nominal_kWh": 30.0,
      "usable_for_propulsion_bus_kWh": 15.04,
      "total_DC_kW": 9.582210757056773,
      "hours": 1.5695751618616678,
      "range_nm": 10.987026133031675,
      "assumptions": "SOC90-10, discharge .96, reserve8kWh, hotel232W, no solar/kite; same KIMI resistance"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 7.0,
      "nominal_kWh": 40.0,
      "usable_for_propulsion_bus_kWh": 22.72,
      "total_DC_kW": 9.582210757056773,
      "hours": 2.3710603508974133,
      "range_nm": 16.597422456281894,
      "assumptions": "SOC90-10, discharge .96, reserve8kWh, hotel232W, no solar/kite; same KIMI resistance"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 7.0,
      "nominal_kWh": 48.2304,
      "usable_for_propulsion_bus_kWh": 29.040947200000005,
      "total_DC_kW": 9.582210757056773,
      "hours": 3.030714720881394,
      "range_nm": 21.215003046169755,
      "assumptions": "SOC90-10, discharge .96, reserve8kWh, hotel232W, no solar/kite; same KIMI resistance"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 8.0,
      "nominal_kWh": 30.0,
      "usable_for_propulsion_bus_kWh": 15.04,
      "total_DC_kW": 14.780029054791516,
      "hours": 1.0175893392526318,
      "range_nm": 8.140714714021055,
      "assumptions": "SOC90-10, discharge .96, reserve8kWh, hotel232W, no solar/kite; same KIMI resistance"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 8.0,
      "nominal_kWh": 40.0,
      "usable_for_propulsion_bus_kWh": 22.72,
      "total_DC_kW": 14.780029054791516,
      "hours": 1.5372094273816352,
      "range_nm": 12.297675419053082,
      "assumptions": "SOC90-10, discharge .96, reserve8kWh, hotel232W, no solar/kite; same KIMI resistance"
    },
    {
      "speed_kn": 8.0,
      "nominal_kWh": 48.2304,
      "usable_for_propulsion_bus_kWh": 29.040947200000005,
      "total_DC_kW": 14.780029054791516,
      "hours": 1.9648775447153308,
      "range_nm": 15.719020357722647,
      "assumptions": "SOC90-10, discharge .96, reserve8kWh, hotel232W, no solar/kite; same KIMI resistance"
    }
  ],
  "battery": {
    "topology_candidate": "2 independent 24S1P banks, 24 cells per hull, 48 total; parallel connection only after compatible protection design",
    "nominal_cell_V_assumed": 3.2,
    "Ah_assumed_from_KIMI_budget": 314,
    "charge_cell_V_assumed": 3.65,
    "series_cells": 24,
    "parallel_total": 2,
    "total_cells": 48,
    "nominal_V": 76.8,
    "full_charge_V_scenario": 87.6,
    "nominal_Ah": 628,
    "nominal_energy_kWh": 48.23040000000001,
    "two_24S2P_banks_kWh": 96.46080000000002,
    "approved": false
  },
  "solar": {
    "roof_projected_m2": 24.679534948644317,
    "module_efficiency_assumed": 0.22,
    "coverage_scenarios": [
      {
        "coverage": 0.7,
        "area_m2": 17.275674464051022,
        "kWp": 3.8006483820912247
      },
      {
        "coverage": 0.8,
        "area_m2": 19.743627958915454,
        "kWp": 4.3435981509614
      },
      {
        "coverage": 0.85,
        "area_m2": 20.97760470634767,
        "kWp": 4.615073035396487
      },
      {
        "coverage": 1.0,
        "area_m2": 24.679534948644317,
        "kWp": 5.429497688701749
      }
    ],
    "coverage_needed_for_5kWp_at_22pct": 0.9208955020654136,
    "route_forecast_available": false,
    "diesel400L_mass_assumed_kg": 336.0,
    "diesel_density_assumed_kg_L": 0.84,
    "diesel_case_not_baseline": true
  },
  "budget": {
    "sum_low_USD": 117200,
    "sum_high_USD": 198638,
    "reported_subtotal_low_USD": 117200,
    "reported_subtotal_high_USD": 198638,
    "reported_total_low_USD": 128920.00000000001,
    "reported_total_high_USD": 218501.80000000002,
    "prices_revalidated": false,
    "labor_hours": [
      3500,
      4500
    ],
    "source": "budget15.json; not a procurement quote"
  },
  "panel_volume_audit": {
    "dry_fiber_kg_m2": 1.4,
    "resin_fiber_ratio": 0.7,
    "glass_rho_assumed": 2550,
    "resin_rho_assumed": 1150,
    "used_thickness_mm": 0.78,
    "consistent_thickness_mm": 1.4011935208866155,
    "mass_at_74_m2_kg": 500.24,
    "mass_at_current_116_m2_kg": 784.2492120374436,
    "scope": "same A areal mass, illustrates area and volume bookkeeping only; not a compliant T11 panel design"
  },
  "motor_efficiency_column_check": [
    {
      "row": 1,
      "Pout_W": 969.1,
      "Pin_W": 1933,
      "controller_pct": 96.4,
      "motor_pct": 52.0,
      "combined_pct": 50.1
    },
    {
      "row": 20,
      "Pout_W": 12868,
      "Pin_W": 14054,
      "controller_pct": 95.3,
      "motor_pct": 96.0,
      "combined_pct": 91.6
    },
    {
      "row": 35,
      "Pout_W": 18027,
      "Pin_W": 19964,
      "controller_pct": 95.9,
      "motor_pct": 94.2,
      "combined_pct": 90.3
    }
  ],
  "issues": [
    {
      "id": "K01",
      "topic": "Масса и осадка",
      "severity": "critical",
      "imported_claim": "7,2 т и перегруз 8,6 т приняты как рабочие",
      "resolution": "Не соответствуют DRAFT-001. При 0,52 м допустим только геометрический предел 6944,1/6774,7 кг; 6500 кг остаётся предложенной целью.",
      "evidence": [
        "ПЕРЕНОС_ПРОЕКТА.md:2",
        "hydro_results.json",
        "calculations/draft-052/results.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K02",
      "topic": "Геометрия и координаты",
      "severity": "high",
      "imported_claim": "OBJ Mesh54 принят замкнутым; LCB от кормы 7,82 м",
      "resolution": "Mesh54 содержит разные наружные поверхности и не проверен как два Solid. В hydro.py LCB отсчитывается от xmin и X не развёрнут, в нашей CAD X направлен противоположно; нагрузки и CG без преобразования не переносить.",
      "evidence": [
        "hydro.py:162",
        "research/geometry/ECONA_audit.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K03",
      "topic": "Дифферент",
      "severity": "critical",
      "imported_claim": "Угол около 0,93° из плеча 0,219 м",
      "resolution": "atan(плечо/L) не решает гидростатическое равновесие. При том же предположенном GM_L=39 м линейный угол 0,322°, но фактическая посадка требует Ship SinkAndTrim и действительных CG/танков.",
      "evidence": [
        "stage9_layout.py:167",
        "stage11_trim.py:27"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K04",
      "topic": "Остойчивость",
      "severity": "critical",
      "imported_claim": "RMmax=200,4 кНм, θ*=9,4°, безопасный ветер до 29,3 м/с",
      "resolution": "Это грубая модель отрыва корпуса, а не действительная GZ, динамика и непроницаемые границы. Не принимать как штормовой конверт или допустимую тягу.",
      "evidence": [
        "kite_stability.py:44",
        "kite_stab.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K05",
      "topic": "Регулятор кайта",
      "severity": "high",
      "imported_claim": "Порыв отрабатывается за 0,6 с",
      "resolution": "0,6 с - первое попадание в ±5%, а не устойчивое установление. Модель без динамики исполнительного механизма/троса; рекуррентный закон не стандартный позиционный PI.",
      "evidence": [
        "stage13_kite.py:120",
        "stage13_kite.py:114"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K06",
      "topic": "Поляра кайта",
      "severity": "high",
      "imported_claim": "75–180°, 13 уз, 200–310 миль/сут доказаны",
      "resolution": "Тяга и проекция назначены, верхняя скорость ограничена числом 13 в коде. Это сценарная поляра; нужна динамика движущегося судна/кайта и маршрутная погода.",
      "evidence": [
        "stage13_kite.py:52",
        "stage13_kite.py:35"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K07",
      "topic": "Длина троса и высота",
      "severity": "high",
      "imported_claim": "Трос 25–35 м и преимущества ветра на 100–300 м",
      "resolution": "Одна геометрия не обеспечивает обе высоты: при 35 м и 30° подъём только 17,5 м над точкой крепления. Длина и запуск остаются открытыми.",
      "evidence": [
        "report16.md:18",
        "report16.md:34"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K08",
      "topic": "Нормативы",
      "severity": "high",
      "imported_claim": "ГОСТ 11539-2014 - маломерные суда",
      "resolution": "Исправлено: бакелизированная фанера. ISO 12215-6 - конструктивные детали; нагрузки многокорпусника - ISO 12215-7. Океанская миссия не является доказанной категорией или автоматически a=2,5g.",
      "evidence": [
        "knowledge_base.md:23",
        "verified-web/manifest.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K09",
      "topic": "Общая прочность",
      "severity": "critical",
      "imported_claim": "Все проверки моста пройдены; +502 кг достаточно",
      "resolution": "Условная коробчатая схема, типовые прочности, равномерный поток по сумме площадей контуров, сложение клея/болтов и Мизес для композита не подтверждают реальную конструкцию. Сохранить весь верхний набор; нужен FEM с материалами и соединениями.",
      "evidence": [
        "bridge_strength.py",
        "bridge_strength.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K10",
      "topic": "Панели",
      "severity": "high",
      "imported_claim": "Пакет A выбран и обшивка около 500 кг",
      "resolution": "Назначено 74 м² вместо измеренных 116,013 м²; ткань biax и толщины отличаются от Т11 3/2. Массу 500 кг не переносить. В прогибе пропущен сдвиг ядра; масса/толщина обкладки не согласованы.",
      "evidence": [
        "hull_panels.py:83",
        "hull_panels.py:113",
        "weights.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K11",
      "topic": "КПД мотора",
      "severity": "high",
      "imported_claim": "КПД мотора 96–97% по 72V20KWW",
      "resolution": "В DATA первого набора под именем мотор использован Control_Eff. По фото строка35: контроллер95,9%, мотор94,2%, общий90,3%; строки разделены в новом паспорте.",
      "evidence": [
        "stage10_motors.py:15",
        "bldc_20kw/H76dcb80de1ce43b588b3902e6f7125d0h.jpg"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K12",
      "topic": "Мощность и охлаждение",
      "severity": "high",
      "imported_claim": "20 кВт, 55 Нм, 3200 rpm, забортная вода",
      "resolution": "55 Нм×3200 rpm=18,43 кВт. Непрерывные 20 кВт и совместимость с солёной водой не доказаны. 72 В сохраняется; покупка и мощность не выбраны.",
      "evidence": [
        "stage10_motors.json",
        "research/motors/goldenmotor-hpm/reference.yaml"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K13",
      "topic": "Привод и винт",
      "severity": "high",
      "imported_claim": "10,1 уз при 33,3 кВт DC; винт B3-50 складной подтверждён",
      "resolution": "В расчёте DC отсутствует редуктор .97, а при отдельной валовой потере .98 отсутствует и она: тот же пример требует около35,0кВт DC. B-series не доказывает характеристики конкретного складного винта и морскую кавитацию.",
      "evidence": [
        "stage12_final.py:127",
        "stage12_prop.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K14",
      "topic": "Энергия АКБ",
      "severity": "high",
      "imported_claim": "40 кВтч в расчётах, 24S2P/48 кВтч в спецификации",
      "resolution": "Варианты разделены. 24S2P при314Ач и3,2В =48,2304кВтч; два банка по24S1P. 24S/87,6В - кандидат, не принятое число ячеек.",
      "evidence": [
        "stage14_energy.json",
        "budget15.json",
        "stage10_motors.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K15",
      "topic": "Дальность",
      "severity": "high",
      "imported_claim": "28 миль при7уз и40кВтч; до1166 с ДГУ",
      "resolution": "Первый результат воспроизводится как40×.9/P без бортовой нагрузки/резерва. На общей принятой для сравнения схеме SOC/потерь/резерва результат иной; ДГУ и топливо оставлены только отдельным вариантом.",
      "evidence": [
        "stage14_energy.json",
        "stage8_energy.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K16",
      "topic": "Солнечная крыша",
      "severity": "medium",
      "imported_claim": "5кВтп/25м² и20кВтч/сут",
      "resolution": "Крыша измерена24,68м² до проходов/люков. При22% и70–85% покрытии3,8–4,6кВтп;5кВтп требуют92,1% покрытия. 20кВтч/сут - погодный сценарий, не кругосветный прогноз.",
      "evidence": [
        "stage8_energy.py",
        "calculations/concept-v2/results.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K17",
      "topic": "ДГУ и берег",
      "severity": "high",
      "imported_claim": "ДГУ15кВт,400л, береговая зарядка - базовые",
      "resolution": "Не подменяют прямой принцип пользователя об автономности от денег/берега. Сохранены для сравнения; 400л при0,84кг/л добавляют336кг топлива без генератора/баков.",
      "evidence": [
        "ПЕРЕНОС_ПРОЕКТА.md",
        "weights.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K18",
      "topic": "Бюджет и комплектующие",
      "severity": "medium",
      "imported_claim": "140–148тыс.USD, SmartSolar×4, IBT-2 хватит",
      "resolution": "Суммы исходной сметы проверены, цены/совместимость не подтверждены. Для MPPT проверить заряд до верхнего U АКБ; для рулевого драйвера - реальную нагрузку/нагрев. Номинал43А платы не подбор привода.",
      "evidence": [
        "budget15.json",
        "knowledge_base.md:150"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "C01",
      "topic": "Наше сравнение материалов",
      "severity": "medium",
      "imported_claim": "Оптимальные пакеты из971 вариантов",
      "resolution": "Повторный тест пройден. Уточнено: это минимум выбранной сетки плоских полос, а не всей конструкции; площади/нахлёсты/неподтверждённые G и прочности остаются допущениями.",
      "evidence": [
        "tools/concept/verify_skin_comparison.py",
        "calculations/skin-comparison/verification.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "C02",
      "topic": "Наши общие сценарии",
      "severity": "medium",
      "imported_claim": "Скорость/энергетика и бюджета6500кг",
      "resolution": "Сохранены как сценарии. Отдельного подтверждения полного сопротивления, GZ, масс/CG и океанской прочности нет; старые бюджеты7,05–8,86т не становятся текущими.",
      "evidence": [
        "docs/23_concept_analysis.md",
        "calculations/concept-v2/results.json"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "K19",
      "topic": "Совместимость MPPT",
      "severity": "high",
      "imported_claim": "В смете SmartSolar×4 для72В без модели",
      "resolution": "Например, SmartSolar 250/100 VE.Can поддерживает АКБ12/24/48В (36В вручную), не 24S LiFePO4. 250В относится к PV-входу. Требуется подходящий выходной диапазон до верхнего напряжения выбранного банка.",
      "evidence": [
        "budget15.json",
        "Victron official technical specifications"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "C03",
      "topic": "Наш классификатор панелей",
      "severity": "medium",
      "imported_claim": "Сравнение core_screen через is not False",
      "resolution": "Исправлена обработка NumPy bool_: непрошедший сдвиг теперь всегда отклоняет сценарный экран. Добавлен тест; прежние971 базовых вариантов не изменились.",
      "evidence": [
        "tools/concept/compare_skins.py",
        "tools/concept/verify_skin_comparison.py"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "C04",
      "topic": "Наша чувствительность смолы",
      "severity": "medium",
      "imported_claim": "Механический пересчёт с той же E при другой доле смолы",
      "resolution": "Убраны механические прогнозы из resin_sensitivity. Сохранён массовый пересчёт; новый E/G/прочность нужно задать по фактическому ламинату.",
      "evidence": [
        "tools/concept/compare_skins.py",
        "calculations/skin-comparison/results.json"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "checks": {
    "ship_independent_match": true,
    "skin_tests_passed": true,
    "budget_arithmetic_passed": true,
    "battery_arithmetic_passed": true,
    "reproduced_first_PI_entry": true
  },
  "scope": "Independent arithmetic and selected code/source audit; no physical tests, final structural approval, real GZ or calibrated resistance implied"
}